Dreamkeepers Chapters 3 & 4

 I actually started to laugh out loud while reading a quotation from Devereaux on page 42. She describes the condition of her desk and how it gets that way. I was just pointing out to my coworker yesterday that I am embarrassed about the corner I call my work area. When I try and describe my job to other people they have a hard time understanding that I don’t sit at my desk, I can’t check my email or phone and I barely have time to breathe. Throughout the day I feel so involved in my lessons and spend every moment I am not teaching the whole class walking around helping students. I was laughing because I say “put it on my desk” several times throughout the day. When I finally have a moment to sit at about 4:15pm I have piles to take care of before I can even reach my computer. I often feel that the job requires a lot of paperwork without being given the time to complete the paperwork. Now there is not only paperwork but electronic work as well. The number of emails that pile up throughout the day takes about an hour just to sort through and reply. I then still have phone calls to return. As Devereaux mentions, I often feel that my job working with people, often turns into working with paper.

Valentine’s explanation for why she enjoys teaching African Americans made me consider the difficulties I have been having in my classroom. Valentine believes she can relate to her students and knows how they live and learn. Although there are certainly many similarities between my students and myself, there is an apparent difference between us. I grew up in a white suburban area, attending predominately white schools. The students I teach are African Americans living in the city. I do feel separated from them sometimes, as I cannot relate to experiences or beliefs they may have. I may look at something my students say or do and think of it as a sign of needing help. I often have to take a step back and make sure that I am not just seeing a cultural difference. Although this may get easier with more experience teaching in an urban school, there is no way to completely fill the gap between my students and myself.

Dreamkeepers Chapters 1 & 2

Although I have to admit that I am hesitant to categorize all African Americans under one style of teaching or one culture, I can’t stop thinking about the statistic mentioned in the book on p. 2 “African American students make up only 17 percent of the public school population but 41 percent of the special education population.” I go back and forth on the idea that African Americans should be taught in a special way, or that teachers should be prepared before teaching them. Part of me feels like it may not be based on race, but more on the environment in which some students grow up. I think instead of classifying the type of teaching Dreamkeepers is based on as teaching African Americans, instead it should be classified as urban students. But then I argue with myself and look at the previous statistic and believe that numbers can’t lie. From my three years of teaching I have to admit that all the African American students I have taught are different from the white students. However, the black students I taught in Massachusetts were being bused in from Boston so there is no fair comparison. The one African American student in my class who was not from the city, acted and achieved just as her white classmates did. My experiences cannot argue with facts, however, I am still hesitant to completely agree that all African Americans should be taught in a different way than other races.